Check the progress of a manuscript by finding its assigned number in the first column and then reading across for the latest information about its travels through the review process. The journal uses a two-tier review procedure. Manuscripts are first reviewed by the Editor for appropriateness of content and overall quality. Manuscripts that are not appropriate for the journal or that have obvious and major flaws are rejected without additional review. Those that pass this initial screen are then sent out for review by members of the editorial board and other experts in the field. Ordinarily two reviews are sought, although additional reviews may be requested for manuscripts that report complex methodology, that cover topics spanning many content areas, or that result in drastic differences of opinion between reviewers. Manuscripts with an "R" designation are revisions; manuscripts with an "S" designation are special issue submissions; manuscripts with an "I" designation are invited submissions.
Manuscript |
Date |
Sent
For |
Reviews |
Decision |
Comments |
| 98-1-1 | 1/2/98 | 1/6/98 | |||
| 98-1-2 | 1/2/98 | 1/5/98 | 2 | 2/20/98 | |
| 98-1-2R | 6/16/98 | 6/27/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-1-3 | 1/2/98 | 1/5/98 | 2 | 2/20/98 | |
| 98-1-3R | 5/20/98 | 6/29/98 | |||
| 98-1-3RR | 7/15/98 | 8/21/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-1-4 | 1/12/98 | 1/20/98 | 2 | 3/5/98 | |
| 98-1-4R | 7/13/98 | 9/16/98 | |||
| 98-1-4RR | 11/13/98 | 12/8/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-1-5 | 1/13/98 | 1/20/98 | 2 | 2/24/98 | |
| 98-1-6S | 1/12/98 | 1/22/98 | 2 | 6/5/98 | |
| 98-1-7S | 1/12/98 | 1/22/98 | 3 | 5/19/98 | |
| 98-1-7SR | 10/27/98 | 11/3/98 | 3 | 2/12/99 | |
| 98-1-7SRR | 4/20/99 | 6/21/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-1-8S | 1/15/98 | 1/23/98 | 2 | 3/10/98 | |
| 98-1-8SR | 7/15/98 | 7/17/98 | 1 | 8/31/98 | Accepted |
| 98-1-9 | 1/16/98 | 1/20/98 | 2 | 3/3/98 | |
| 98-1-9R | 3/11/99 | 8/2/99 | |||
| 98-1-10 | 1/21/98 | 1/23/98 | 2 | 2/27/98 | |
| 98-1-11 | 1/23/98 | 1/24/98 | |||
| 98-1-12 | 1/29/98 | 2/1/98 | |||
| 98-1-13 | 1/29/98 | 2/2/98 | 2 | 3/25/98 | |
| 98-1-13R | 4/20/98 | 4/21/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-1-14S | 1/29/98 | 2/5/98 | 2 | 4/28/98 | |
| 98-1-15S | 1/26/98 | 2/5/98 | 3 | 6/9/98 | |
| 98-1-15SR | 11/24/98 | 11/30/98 | 3 | 4/5/99 | Accepted |
| 98-2-16 | 2/2/98 | 2/3/98 | 2 | 3/31/98 | |
| 98-2-16R | 11/3/98 | 12/8/98 | |||
| 98-2-16RR | 4/2/99 | 7/10/99 | |||
| 98-2-16RRR | 11/19/99 | 11/25/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-2-17 | 2/3/98 | 2/7/98 | 2 | 3/13/98 | |
| 98-2-17R | 6/22/98 | 6/29/98 | 2 | 9/16/98 | |
| 98-2-18 | 2/3/98 | 2/7/98 | 2 | 3/22/98 | |
| 98-2-19 | 2/3/98 | 2/7/98 | 2 | 3/5/98 | |
| 98-2-20 | 2/6/98 | 2/9/98 | 2 | 4/16/98 | |
| 98-2-21 | 2/9/98 | 2/11/98 | 2 | 3/28/98 | |
| 98-2-22 | 2/13/98 | 2/14/98 | 2 | 3/19/98 | |
| 98-2-23 | 2/18/98 | 2/19/98 | |||
| 98-2-24 | 2/23/98 | 2/25/98 | 2 | 4/8/98 | |
| 98-2-25S | 2/16/98 | 3/3/98 | 2 | 7/8/98 | |
| 98-3-26 | 3/6/98 | 3/10/98 | |||
| 98-3-27 | 3/6/98 | 3/10/98 | |||
| 98-3-28 | 3/6/98 | 3/11/98 | 2 | 4/18/98 | |
| 98-3-29 | 3/6/98 | 3/11/98 | 2 | 4/18/98 | |
| 98-3-30 | 3/6/98 | 3/11/98 | 2 | 4/24/98 | |
| 98-3-30R | 6/22/98 | 6/26/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-3-31S | 3/4/98 | 3/17/98 | 2 | 6/30/98 | |
| 98-3-31SR | 8/11/98 | 9/1/98 | 3 | 12/15/98 | |
| 98-3-31SRR | 1/8/99 | 4/5/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-3-32 | 3/6/98 | 3/10/98 | |||
| 98-3-33S | 3/12/98 | 3/26/98 | 2 | 7/10/98 | |
| 98-3-33SR | 4/2/99 | 4/5/99 | 2 | 9/20/99 | Accepted |
| 98-3-34 | 3/13/98 | 3/23/98 | |||
| 98-3-35 | 3/19/98 | 3/24/98 | 1 | 4/30/98 | |
| 98-3-35R | 8/14/98 | 11/5/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-3-36 | 3/20/98 | 3/23/98 | |||
| 98-3-37 | 3/23/98 | 3/24/98 | 2 | 5/8/98 | |
| 98-3-38 | 3/23/98 | 3/23/98 | |||
| 98-3-39 | 3/24/98 | 3/28/98 | 2 | 4/30/98 | |
| 98-3-39R | 6/1/98 | 6/30/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-3-40 | 3/26/98 | 3/28/98 | 1 | 5/21/98 | |
| 98-3-41 | 3/26/98 | 3/28/98 | 2 | 4/30/98 | |
| 98-3-41R | 8/12/98 | 10/14/98 | |||
| 98-3-42 | 3/27/98 | 3/28/98 | |||
| 98-3-43 | 3/30/98 | 4/1/98 | 2 | 5/13/98 | |
| 98-3-43R | 12/10/98 | 5/18/99 | |||
| 98-3-43RR | 6/17/99 | 7/21/99 | |||
| 98-3-43RRR | 8/20/99 | 9/7/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-3-44 | 3/30/98 | 4/1/98 | 2 | 5/13/98 | |
| 98-3-45 | 3/30/98 | 4/1/98 | |||
| 98-4-46 | 4/6/98 | 4/7/98 | 2 | 6/19/98 | |
| 98-4-47 | 4/6/98 | 4/7/98 | 2 | 5/20/98 | |
| 98-4-48 | 4/13/98 | 4/15/98 | 3 | 6/19/98 | |
| 98-4-48R | 9/29/98 | 11/10/98 | |||
| 98-4-48RR | 1/14/99 | 2/9/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-4-49 | 4/13/98 | 4/15/98 | 2 | 5/20/98 | |
| 98-4-50 | 4/16/98 | 4/18/98 | |||
| 98-4-51 | 4/16/98 | 4/18/98 | |||
| 98-4-52 | 4/17/98 | 4/18/98 | |||
| 98-4-53 | 4/17/98 | 4/18/98 | |||
| 98-4-54 | 4/20/98 | 4/21/98 | |||
| 98-4-55 | 4/27/98 | 4/28/98 | |||
| 98-4-56 | 4/27/98 | 4/28/98 | |||
| 98-4-57 | 4/29/98 | 5/7/98 | 2 | 7/1/98 | |
| 98-4-57R | 9/29/98 | 10/5/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-5-58 | 5/4/98 | 5/5/98 | 2 | 6/19/98 | |
| 98-5-59 | 5/11/98 | 5/13/98 | 1 | 8/4/98 | |
| 98-5-59R | 10/9/98 | 11/5/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-5-60S | 5/21/98 | 6/4/98 | 2 | 12/29/98 | |
| 98-5-60SR | 5/14/99 | 5/19/99 | 2 | 10/5/99 | Accepted |
| 98-5-61 | 5/22/98 | 5/22/98 | |||
| 98-5-62 | 5/28/98 | 6/2/98 | |||
| 98-5-63 | 5/29/98 | 6/1/98 | 2 | 8/3/98 | |
| 98-6-64 | 6/1/98 | 6/2/98 | 2 | 7/9/98 | |
| 98-6-65 | 6/5/98 | 6/9/98 | 2 | 8/3/98 | |
| 98-6-65R | 1/22/99 | 6/25/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-6-66S | 6/19/98 | 7/22/98 | 2 | 1/25/99 | |
| 98-6-66SR | 3/26/99 | 4/5/99 | 2 | 5/27/99 | Accepted |
| 98-6-67S | 6/22/98 | 7/13/98 | 2 | 11/16/98 | |
| 98-6-68S | 6/15/98 | 7/13/98 | 2 | 1/29/99 | |
| 98-6-68SR | 3/31/99 | 4/5/99 | 1 | 6/28/99 | Accepted |
| 98-6-69S | 6/12/98 | 7/17/98 | 2 | 12/17/98 | |
| 98-6-69SR | 2/22/99 | 3/2/99 | 2 | 6/4/99 | |
| 98-6-69SRR | 7/7/99 | 7/19/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-6-70S | 6/18/98 | 7/13/98 | 2 | 5/5/99 | |
| 98-6-70SR | 6/16/99 | 6/21/99 | 2 | 10/11/99 | Accepted |
| 98-6-71 | 6/19/98 | 6/24/98 | 2 | 8/8/98 | |
| 98-6-72 | 6/19/98 | 6/24/98 | |||
| 98-6-73 | 6/19/98 | 6/24/98 | 2 | 8/6/98 | |
| 98-6-74 | 6/19/98 | 6/24/98 | |||
| 98-6-75 | 6/22/98 | 6/24/98 | |||
| 98-6-76 | 6/22/98 | 6/24/98 | 2 | 8/10/98 | |
| 98-6-76R | 11/6/98 | 11/10/98 | |||
| 98-6-76RR | 1/26/99 | 6/22/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-6-77 | 6/22/98 | 6/24/98 | 2 | 8/10/98 | |
| 98-6-78S | 6/24/98 | 7/15/98 | 3 | 9/28/98 | |
| 98-6-79 | 6/24/98 | 6/24/98 | |||
| 98-6-80S | 6/24/98 | 7/22/98 | 2 | 5/12/99 | |
| 98-6-80SR | 8/26/99 | 9/16/99 | 2 | 12/20/99 | Accepted |
| 98-6-81S | 6/26/98 | 7/17/98 | 2 | 12/30/98 | |
| 98-6-82S | 6/26/98 | 7/20/98 | 2 | 5/12/99 | |
| 98-6-82SR | 7/20/99 | 8/2/99 | 2 | 10/11/99 | Accepted |
| 98-6-83 | 6/26/98 | 6/29/98 | 2 | 8/14/98 | |
| 98-6-84 | 6/29/98 | 6/30/98 | |||
| 98-6-85S | 6/29/98 | 7/23/98 | 2 | 3/12/99 | |
| 98-6-85SR | 6/29/99 | 7/7/99 | 2 | 9/16/99 | Accepted |
| 98-7-86S | 6/30/98 | 7/20/98 | 3 | 4/14/99 | |
| 98-7-86SR | 8/15/99 | 9/16/99 | 12/10/99 | Accepted | |
| 98-7-87S | 6/30/98 | 7/22/98 | 2 | 12/12/98 | |
| 98-7-88 | 7/13/98 | 7/17/98 | 3 | 9/6/98 | |
| 98-7-88R | 1/22/99 | 5/23/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-89 | 7/13/98 | 7/17/98 | 2 | 8/19/98 | |
| 98-7-90 | 7/13/98 | 7/17/98 | 2 | 8/19/98 | |
| 98-7-90R | 9/16/98 | 9/26/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-91 | 7/13/98 | 7/17/98 | |||
| 98-7-92 | 7/13/98 | 7/17/98 | 2 | 8/31/98 | |
| 98-7-92R | 11/2/99 | 11/2/00 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-93 | 7/15/98 | 7/17/98 | 2 | 9/6/98 | |
| 98-7-93R | 2/15/99 | 7/9/99 | |||
| 98-7-93RR | 9/7/99 | ||||
| 98-7-94 | 7/16/98 | 7/17/98 | 1 | 9/8/98 | |
| 98-7-95S | 7/15/98 | 7/24/98 | 4/5/99 | ||
| 98-7-96S | 7/11/98 | 7/27/98 | 5/10/99 | ||
| 98-7-97S | 7/11/98 | 7/27/98 | 2 | 5/10/99 | |
| 98-7-97-SR | 7/20/99 | 7/30/99 | 2 | 9/20/99 | Accepted |
| 98-7-98S | 7/15/98 | 7/24/98 | 2 | 2/12/99 | |
| 98-7-98SR | 7/23/99 | 8/2/99 | 10/11/99 | ||
| 98-7-99S | 7/17/98 | 10/12/98 | 1 | 2/15/99 | |
| 98-7-99SR | 5/20/99 | 6/21/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-100S | 7/17/98 | 7/24/98 | 1 | 1/22/99 | |
| 98-7-100SR | 6/6/99 | 6/24/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-101S | 7/18/98 | 7/24/98 | 2 | 12/18/98 | |
| 98-7-101SR | 5/10/99 | 6/23/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-102S | 7/22/98 | 7/27/98 | 2 | 3/27/99 | |
| 98-7-103 | 7/20/98 | 7/25/98 | 2 | 9/24/98 | |
| 98-7-104 | 7/20/98 | 7/25/98 | 2 | 9/12/98 | |
| 98-7-104R | 10/16/98 | 11/5/98 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-105 | 7/20/98 | 7/25/98 | 2 | 9/3/98 | |
| 98-7-106 | 7/23/98 | 7/25/98 | |||
| 98-7-107 | 7/23/98 | 7/25/98 | 2 | 9/10/98 | |
| 98-7-107R | 3/5/99 | 7/11/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-108 | 7/23/98 | 7/25/98 | 2 | 9/2/98 | |
| 98-7-108R | 1/26/99 | 6/23/99 | |||
| 98-7-108RR | 10/6/99 | 8/31/00 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-109 | 7/31/98 | 8/4/98 | 2 | 9/3/98 | |
| 98-7-110 | 7/31/98 | 8/4/98 | 2 | 10/2/98 | |
| 98-7-110R | 8/14/02 | 8/15/02 | Accepted | ||
| 98-7-111 | 7/31/98 | 8/4/98 | 2 | 9/8/98 | |
| 98-7-111R | 12/17/99 | 11/2/00 | |||
| 98-7-111RR | 10/17/01 | 12/14/01 | |||
| 98-8-112 | 8/3/98 | 8/4/98 | |||
| 98-8-113 | 8/3/98 | 8/4/98 | 2 | 9/17/98 | |
| 98-8-113R | 1/4/99 | 2/9/99 | |||
| 98-8-113RR | 2/22/99 | 5/22/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-8-114 | 8/10/98 | 8/13/98 | 2 | 10/1/98 | |
| 98-8-114R | 3/5/99 | 7/8/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-8-115 | 8/10/98 | 8/13/98 | |||
| 98-8-116 | 8/10/98 | 8/13/98 | |||
| 98-8-117 | 8/12/98 | 8/13/98 | |||
| 98-8-118 | 8/12/98 | 8/13/98 | |||
| 98-8-119 | 8/20/98 | 8/25/98 | |||
| 98-8-120 | 8/24/98 | 8/25/98 | |||
| 98-8-121 | 8/26/98 | 8/27/98 | 2 | 10/14/98 | |
| 98-8-121R | 4/22/98 | 7/8/99 | |||
| 98-8-121RR | 8/2/99 | 8/9/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-8-122 | 8/28/98 | 9/3/98 | 2 | 10/14/98 | |
| 98-9-123 | 9/2/98 | 9/3/98 | |||
| 98-9-124 | 9/2/98 | 9/3/98 | |||
| 98-9-125 | 9/4/98 | 9/5/98 | 2 | 10/15/98 | |
| 98-9-125R | 1/4/99 | 2/9/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-9-126S | 7/27/98 | 9/30/98 | 3 | 12/10/98 | |
| 98-9-126SR | 4/5/99 | 4/20/99 | 3 | 6/29/99 | Accepted |
| 98-9-127 | 9/9/98 | 9/9/98 | |||
| 98-9-128 | 9/17/98 | 9/19/98 | 2 | 11/3/98 | |
| 98-9-129 | 9/17/98 | 9/17/98 | |||
| 98-9-130 | 9/21/98 | 9/22/98 | 2 | 11/3/98 | |
| 98-9-131 | 9/25/98 | 9/26/98 | |||
| 98-9-132 | 9/25/98 | 9/26/98 | 2 | 10/26/98 | |
| 98-9-132R | 3/5/99 | 7/26/99 | |||
| 98-9-133 | 9/29/98 | 10/3/98 | |||
| 98-9-134 | 9/30/98 | 10/3/98 | |||
| 98-9-134R | 12/14/98 | 2/16/99 | |||
| 98-10-135 | 10/2/98 | 10/5/98 | |||
| 98-10-136 | 10/5/98 | 10/6/98 | 1 | 1/10/99 | |
| 98-10-136R | 9/19/00 | 12/9/00 | Accepted | ||
| 98-10-137 | 10/7/98 | 10/7/98 | |||
| 98-10-138 | 10/9/98 | 10/10/98 | 2 | 11/19/98 | |
| 98-10-138R | 1/11/99 | 2/6/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-10-139 | 10/9/98 | 10/10/98 | |||
| 98-10-140 | 10/9/98 | 10/10/98 | |||
| 98-10-141 | 10/14/98 | 10/15/98 | 2 | 11/25/98 | |
| 98-10-141R | 3/19/99 | 7/8/99 | |||
| 98-10-141RR | 9/21/99 | 7/10/00 | Accepted | ||
| 98-10-142 | 10/14/98 | 10/15/98 | 3 | 11/22/98 | |
| 98-10-143 | 10/23/98 | 10/26/98 | 1 | 12/31/98 | |
| 98-10-143R | 5/7/99 | 7/27/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-10-144 | 10/23/98 | 10/26/98 | |||
| 98-10-145 | 10/26/98 | 10/27/98 | 2 | 12/31/98 | |
| 98-10-145R | 4/5/99 | 7/21/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-10-146 | 10/26/98 | 10/27/98 | 2 | 12/31/98 | |
| 98-11-147 | 11/5/98 | 11/7/98 | 2 | 12/24/98 | |
| 98-11-148 | 11/9/98 | 11/10/98 | 2 | 1/10/99 | |
| 98-11-148R | 3/8/99 | 6/28/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-11-149I | 11/13/98 | 11/17/98 | 2 | 11/30/99 | |
| 98-11-149I | 3/27/00 | 7/25/00 | Accepted | ||
| 98-11-150 | 11/17/98 | 11/19/98 | 2 | 1/5/99 | |
| 98-11-151 | 11/17/98 | 11/19/98 | 2 | 1/15/99 | |
| 98-11-151R | 6/28/99 | 7/21/99 | |||
| 98-11-152 | 11/18/98 | 11/19/98 | 2 | 1/26/99 | |
| 98-11-153 | 11/23/98 | 11/24/98 | |||
| 98-11-154 | 11/23/98 | 11/25/98 | 4 | 1/11/99 | |
| 98-11-154R | 4/30/99 | 7/12/99 | |||
| 98-11-155 | 11/30/98 | 12/2/98 | 1 | 1/18/99 | |
| 98-11-156 | 11/30/98 | 12/2/98 | 3 | 1/29/99 | |
| 98-11-157 | 11/30/98 | 12/2/98 | 2 | 1/18/99 | |
| 98-11-157R | 3/11/99 | 7/10/99 | Accepted | ||
| 98-12-158 | 12/7/98 | 12/8/98 | |||
| 98-12-159 | 12/7/98 | 12/8/98 | |||
| 98-12-160 | 12/7/98 | 12/8/98 |
|Home |Announcements
|From the Editor |Editorial
Board |Submitting
Manuscripts |Review
Procedures |Manuscript
Progress|
|Reviewers
(Thanks!) |Facts
and Figures |Past Issues |Current
Issue |Future Issues |Questions
and Answers |Subscriptions|
|Comments
from You |Other
Places to Go |No Frames |Frames|